MysteryQuest 23

Evaluation Materials 1 (Rubric)

Assessing the Evidence and Ratings

	Outstanding	Very good	Competent	Satisfactory	In-progress
Identifies evidence in the documents and photographs	Identifies many relevant details, including the most important information.	Identifies the most important details.	Identifies some relevant details, but important ones are omitted.	Identifies some relevant details, but the most important information is missing.	Identifies no relevant details in the documents and photographs.
Offers plausible ratings	The ratings are highly plausible and highly justifiable in light of the evidence.	The ratings are clearly plausible and justifiable in light of the evidence.	The ratings are plausible and somewhat justifiable in light of the evidence	The ratings are plausible but are barely justifiable in light of the evidence.	The ratings are implausible and not justifiable in light of the evidence.