MysteryQuest 23

Evaluation Materials 2 (Rubric)

Assessing the Recommendation

	Outstanding	Very good	Competent	Satisfactory	In-progress
Identifies reasons for coming	Identifies the most important reasons to come.	Identifies most of the important reasons to come.	Identifies some relevant and important reasons to come.	Identifies very few relevant reasons to come.	Identifies no relevant reasons to come.
Identifies reasons against coming	Identifies the most important reasons not to come.	Identifies most of the important reasons not to come.	Identifies some relevant and important reasons not to come.	Identifies very few relevant reasons not to come.	Identifies no relevant reasons not to come.
Offers a plausible recommendation	The recommendation is highly plausible and highly justifiable in light of the reasons provided.	The recommendation is clearly plausible and justifiable in light of the reasons provided.	The recommendation is plausible and adequately justifiable in light of the reasons provided.	The recommendation is somewhat plausible, but barely justifiable given the reasons provided.	The recommendation is implausible and not justifiable given the reasons provided.